Join our mailing list!
Get our latest staff recommendations, Indie Next picks and exclusive offers of ARCs and galleys right to your inbox.
A Reading Group Guide to Anybody Shining
By Frances O’Roark DowellSummary
Arie Mae desperately wants a friend. Living in the North Carolina mountains in the 1920s, she’s in “a sad and sorry way” because she has so few other twelve-year-olds to choose from. Her pencil races down the paper as she writes letters to a cousin she’s never met, hoping that will bring friendship. And when Tom, a boy from Baltimore, arrives with a group to study traditional crafts, he shines with possibilities. They trade stories and share encounters with a black bear and an elusive ghost. Travel back in time to Arie Mae’s colorful life that’s poor in worldly goods but rich in family, neighbors, music, and unexpected friendships. Discussion Questions
1. The opening letter tells a lot about Arie Mae and her personality. Discuss what the letter, its details, and its language reveal about her and her life. What does the letter foreshadow about the rest of the story?
2. Friendship is at the center of Anybody Shining
. What efforts does Arie Mae take to make a new friend? Discuss what she and Tom do together. Why do they get along so well? Talk about the incident when Tom gets sick on the way to Aunt Jennie’s, and what it shows about him and Arie Mae. What other friendships are important in the story?
3. “Anybody shining, well, they are the one to be my friend,” says Arie Mae when she first meets Tom. Why does she describe him as shining? Why do you think this supplies the title for the book? The ghost of Oza is also shining. How does that connect to the title and to Arie Mae’s view of Tom?
4. Compare Arie Mae and Lucille, and discuss how they get along. How do they each react to Ruth? What does that show about their personalities? Discuss what the sisters have in common with Ruth and how their lives differ from hers.
5. Arie Mae’s family has given Harlan a home and treats him like one of their own. What does it show about her parents? Describe Harlan’s background and Lucille’s role in helping him. What is he like in appearance and personality, and how does he fit into the family?
6. Arie Mae writes of songcatchers and missionaries, “I wonder why there are so many folks who look at us and are unsatisfied by what they see?” What scenes and conversations show what Arie Mae’s family and neighbors think about outsiders coming to help them? Describe their feelings about it, both positive and negative.
7. Describe what you learn about Mama’s sister, Anna. Why did she cut ties with her family? Why did she keep the letters away from Caroline? What made her change her mind?
8. Miss Keller says that the songs on the radio “lack the nobility of our mountain ballads,” Arie Mae reports. Describe the conflict between Arie Mae’s father and the songcatchers. What does Miss Keller mean by the “nobility” of the traditional music? What is Daddy’s attitude toward the traditional and new music? Discuss how the barn dance in Chapter 19 helps resolve their differences.
9. Similarly, the settlement school teaches crafts like weaving cloth and baskets, many of which are rarely practiced in the mountains anymore. Arie Mae says of split-bottom chairs that she’d rather get her chairs from the Sears catalog. Why is the settlement school teaching the crafts? Why do the Baltimore people want to learn them? Explain why Arie Mae and her family might prefer store-bought furniture and clothes.
10. What is the significance of Mama’s apple stack cake? Explain why Arie Mae changes her mind about sharing it at the picnic and how Miss Pittman later reacts to the cake. In what way does that type of cake connect Arie Mae and Caroline?
11. Tom’s tutor says of writing, “It’s all about collecting the details.” Find details in Arie Mae’s letters to Caroline that paint vivid pictures. Choose a person that Arie Mae describes in her letters and identify details that bring them to life for the reader.
12. Near the end, Arie Mae writes to Caroline, “We knowed we was rich, Cousin Caroline, even if we was poor.” What does she mean by this? Discuss ways that her family is rich and ways that they are poor. Consider which outsiders would agree with Arie Mae’s view and why you think that.
13. The story takes place in the mountains of North Carolina in 1924. Elaborate on the setting in terms of time and place, and analyze how important the setting is to the story. What are some indications that life in Baltimore or Raleigh is different from life in Stone Gap?
14. Why did the author choose the device of telling some of the story through letters to Cousin Caroline? Discuss the impact of the letters on the reader, and how the story would be different if it were all a straightforward first person narrative. Talk about Arie Mae’s voice, including her use of colorful language and what it adds to the story.Extension Activities Now and Then
Have students, working alone or in pairs, create a large Venn diagram to compare and contrast their lives with Arie Mae’s. They can consider topics like food, clothes, communication, and transportation as well as the role of family and friends. Once the diagram is complete, have students compare their results and discuss how much the book revealed about Arie Mae’s life. Dear Arie Mae
When Arie Mae saw she had a letter from Cousin Caroline, she “feared it would be short and polite . . . but that weren’t the case at all.” Have students write the letter that Caroline might have sent, using clues from Arie Mae’s last letter. Have the students share their letters in small groups and note the similarities and differences. Traditional Crafts or Sears Catalog?
Have students compile the different views expressed in the book about traditional crafts versus store-bought items. Assign each student one side of the issue and have them debate one another about which is best, combining thoughts from the book with their own ideas. After the debates, discuss the topic as a group and examine the validity of both sides. Genuine Old-Time Music
Arie Mae’s mother sings “Barbry Allen” and her father plays “Cluck Old Hen.” As a class, listen to the versions below of these songs, which were recorded in the 1930s and 1960s. Have students compare the versions and compare the music, including the quality of recordings, to the music they listen to themselves for pleasure.
Cluck Old Hen: https://lomaxky.omeka.net/items/show/743
Barbry Allen: https://lomaxky.omeka.net/items/show/41
and https://lomaxky.omeka.net/items/show/810 Woolly Worm Weather Forecasters?
Arie Mae says that woolly worm stripes can predict winter weather, and Tom shares a weather belief about acorns. As a class, compile a list of weather prediction beliefs, starting with those in the book and ones that students have heard. Have students add to the list through print and digital research, and by asking people they know. They should also look for scientific proof, if any, and share it in a class discussion. And Then What?
Have students pick a time in Arie Mae’s future and write a narrative about what happens to her. It could be in the near future, such as Cousin Caroline’s visit, or it could be when Arie Mae is an older teen or adult. Their ideas should be grounded in the novel and Arie Mae’s character. Have each student present their narrative to the class and answer questions from their classmates.Guide written by Kathleen Odean, a former school librarian and Chair of the 2002 Newbery Award Committee. She gives professional development workshops on books for young people and is the author of
Great Books for Girls and
Great Books about Things Kids Love. This guide has been provided by Simon & Schuster for classroom, library, and reading group use. It may be reproduced in its entirety or excerpted for these purposes.